Antidepressants Plus 'Talk Therapy' Are Effective Therapy For Teen Depression
August 18, 2004
A new study from the Johns Hopkins Children's Center and 12 other medical centers shows the most effective treatment for adolescents with major depressive disorder is a combination of antidepressants and psychotherapy. Researchers say the study's findings indicate this combination treatment may be best for both improving depression and reducing the level of suicidal thinking in adolescents.
The multicenter Treatment for Adolescents with Depression Study (TADS) clinical trial, sponsored by the National Institute of Mental Health, is believed to be the first to examine the individual and combined effectiveness of the antidepressant fluoxetine (Prozac) and cognitive behavioral ("talk") therapy in depressed adolescents. The findings are published in the August 18th issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.
Overall, combined antidepressant and talk therapy treatment yielded the best results, followed by antidepressants alone. However, talk therapy on its own was found to be no more effective than placebo, the researchers say.
"Until this study, there was limited evidence that proved antidepressants were appropriate for use in teenagers with depression," says John Walkup, M.D., a co-author of the study and a child and adolescent psychiatrist at the Johns Hopkins Children's Center. "Not only do the results support the use of antidepressants for depressed teens, but when used in conjunction with talk therapy, these medications actually provide teens with the best chance to alleviate their depression."
Controversy has surrounded the use of Prozac and similar medications (known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) because of reports that they may lead a small number of teenagers and children to become suicidal. In the current study, researchers found that the level of suicidal thoughts, which had been present in 29 percent of the youths at the beginning of the study, decreased significantly regardless of the treatment received, with the combination of fluoxetine and talk therapy showing the greatest reduction. While no patients committed suicide during the study, there were seven cases of attempted suicide during the treatment phase of the study.
However, Walkup says the development of new suicidal thoughts after starting antidepressant medication is unusual. "As long as youths taking antidepressants are monitored closely by their physicians, I believe the benefits of antidepressants for depressed teens really outweigh the risks. Antidepressants can be a safe and effective treatment for teens with depression, a common condition that can be devastating if left untreated," he says.
During the first 12-week section of the study, 439 youths ages 12 to 17 with moderate to severe depression were randomly assigned to a treatment of either fluoxetine; cognitive behavior therapy, during which a therapist reinforces positive thought patterns and behavior; a combination of fluoxetine and talk therapy; or placebo pills.
Using common psychological scales to measure depression severity, researchers found that 71 percent of teens who received fluoxetine and talk therapy improved with treatment, compared with 60.6 percent who received fluoxetine alone, 43.2 percent who received talk therapy alone, and 34.8 percent who received a placebo treatment.
After 12 weeks, patients who were receiving fluoxetine, talk therapy, or a combination of both continued treatment for two more stages, while those who had not responded to placebos were offered the "active" treatment of their choice. However, results to date include only the first 12 weeks of treatment.
The study was led by John S. March, M.D., M.P.H., from Duke University Medical Center. Other TADS sites include: Johns Hopkins Children's Center, Carolinas Medical Center, Case Western Reserve University, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Columbia University, University of Nebraska, New York University, University of Chicago and Northwestern University, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, University of Oregon, University of Texas Southwestern and Wayne State University.
For more information about the Johns Hopkins Children's Center, please visit: http://www.hopkinschildrens.org
Depressed Teens Helped with Combination Drug-Behavioral Therapy
DURHAM, N.C. -- The most effective way of treating teens suffering from major depressive disorder (MDD) is via a combination of antidepressants and cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), according to Duke University Medical Center researchers. They said their findings indicate that such a combination appears the best approach to both alleviating depression and reducing the level of suicidal thinking in adolescents.
The findings result from stage one of the "Treatment for Adolescents with Depression Study" (TADS). The federally funded study is the first multicenter, randomized clinical trial to examine the individual and combined effectiveness of the antidepressant fluoxetine (trade name Prozac) and CBT in adolescents diagnosed with MDD. The results appeared in the Aug. 18, 2004 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.
The study team found that fluoxetine plus CBT offered greater effectiveness in treatment than the drug alone. The CBT used in this study is a depression-specific psychotherapeutic treatment designed to create and reinforce positive thought patterns and behavior in the adolescents, said the researchers. Contrary to expectations, CBT alone offered no greater effectiveness than placebo, they found.
The researchers emphasized that their findings regarding the safety issues of the therapies -- specifically protection against the potential danger of suicide -- are complex. Their results show that suicidal thinking decreased among all treatment groups, with the greatest reduction occurring in the group receiving combination therapy. Although fluoxetine alone did not increase suicidal thoughts, it did seem to increase the risk for harm-related behaviors. This effect, however, seemed to be buffered by concomitant CBT. The complexity will add to the considerable debate about the use of SSRIs and the link to suicide in adolescents, according to the lead author.
"Depression constitutes a significant public health problem among adolescents, and there has been a tremendous need for identifying effective treatments that are also deemed safe," said John March, M.D., chief of child and adolescent psychiatry at Duke and lead investigator on the study. "Children and young adults suffer serious impairments from depression, especially if they remain undiagnosed. Depression is very common, but those affected must be identified and referred for treatment.
"While fluoxetine proved to be an effective treatment, after weighing the risks and benefits I would strongly encourage the use of combination therapy as the best treatment for depressed teenagers."
The randomized, controlled clinical trial enrolled 439 patients between the ages of 12 and 17 with a primary diagnosis of major depressive disorder. None of the patients were taking antidepressants before beginning study treatment and all could be cared for on an outpatient basis. To be considered for the trial, the patients must have experienced a depressive mood in at least two of three areas (home, school or among peers) for at least six weeks prior to the study. Adolescents with other severe behavioral or mental disorders, a history of endangering themselves or others, or dealing with drug abuse or addictions were excluded from the study.
The three-year enrollment took place at 13 academic and community clinics. Patients were randomized into one of four groups for a 12-week treatment period. One group received treatment with fluoxetine alone (10 to 40 milligrams per day); one group received CBT alone (15 one-hour treatment sessions); one group received a combination of fluoxetine (at the dosage above) with CBT; and the final group received placebo alone (placebo pills identical in appearance to those containing fluoxetine). Fluoxetine and placebo were both administered in a double-blind fashion; the CBT alone and CBT with fluoxetine groups were unblinded.
Compared with fluoxetine and CBT alone, the combination therapy proved superior with a 71 percent response rate. Compared to placebo, fluoxetine worked very well with a 60.6 percent response rate. However, CBT alone (43.2 percent response) proved to be not much more effective than placebo (34.8 percent response). Clinically significant suicidal "ideation," meaning suicidal thinking or imaginings, had been present in 29 percent of the study participants at the beginning of the study. By study completion, the level of suicidal ideation improved significantly in all treatment groups. The team found that fluoxetine coupled with CBT offered the greatest reduction in suicidal thoughts. There were seven cases of attempted suicide but no completed suicides.
"Our data show that suicidal thinking gets better with all forms of treatment used in this trial," March said. "Harm-related behaviors occurred at a very low rate among our participants. While harm-related behaviors might be slightly more likely to occur in teens taking the antidepressant, CBT reduces harm-related behaviors to such an extent that the benefits of CBT outweigh the risks associated with the medication. We think this may be one of the reasons why the combination therapy proved to be more effective."
According to the researchers, MDD is common, with one in 20 teens affected at varying levels of severity. Like other forms of depression, MDD has been associated with increased risk of suicidal behavior and with completed suicide. It has also been linked to long-term psychosocial impairment in adulthood. In the United States, 500,000 adolescents attempt suicide every year and 2,000 die as the result of their injuries. According to 2001 statistics from the National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, suicide is the third leading cause of death in Americans aged 10 to 24.
The research was funded by the National Institute of Mental Health, a division of the National Institutes of Health. Eli Lilly & Company, maker of Prozac, provided the fluoxetine and matching placebo used in TADS under an independent educational grant to Duke. The TADS Team authored the research article. Authors include March, Susan Silva, Ph.D., Steven Petrycki, John Curry, Ph.D., Karen Wells, Ph.D., John Fairbank, Ph.D., Barbara Burns, Ph.D., Marisa Domino and Steven McNulty of Duke University Medical Center; and Benedetto Vitiello, M.D., and Joanne Severe of the National Institute of Mental Health.
March has received previous research support from Eli Lilly & Company.
The clinical recruiting sites were Carolinas Medical Center, Case Western Reserve University/University Hospitals of Cleveland, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Columbia University, Johns Hopkins University, University of Nebraska, New York University, University of Chicago and Northwestern University, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, University of Oregon, University of Texas Southwestern and Wayne State University.
The clinical coordinating center was the Duke Clinical Research Institute, the world's largest academic clinical research organization, which performs Phase I through IV clinical trials, outcomes studies and economic analyses.
Back to News